5 Best Newspaper Mailboxes That Keep Papers Dry (2026 Soak Test)

You didn’t subscribe to the Sunday Times to read a wet ball of pulp. Finding the best newspaper mailbox that actually keeps water out is harder than it looks. Most designs are just afterthoughts—too leaky or too small.

In 2026, we are seeing a shift back to dedicated newspaper tubes and integrated “Jumbo” slots. Why? Because Amazon packages are filling up the main box, leaving no room for your news.

We tested the top solutions to answer one question: Which one actually keeps the news dry?

1. Best Overall – Step2 MailMaster XL (The “Tank”)

The Identity: The homeowner who wants to “buy it once and forget it.”

If you live in a snowy or rainy climate, metal boxes rust. The Step2 MailMaster XL is widely considered the best newspaper mailbox for durability because it is made of heavy-duty resin (the same stuff they make playgrounds out of).

Why it Wins: The newspaper slot is molded into the unit, meaning there are no seams for water to leak through. It is a solid tunnel of dry plastic.

⚠️ The Warning: It is big. If you want a “sleek” invisible mailbox, this isn’t it. This is a fortress.

👉 🏰 Check Price on Amazon (Step2 MailMaster)
👉 🔨 Don’t Forget the 4×4 Post (Required for Install)

2. Best Classic Metal – Solar Group “Townhouse”

The Identity: The Traditionalist who loves the classic curb appeal.

This is the box you grew up with. The Solar Group Townhouse is sleek, steel, and looks great on a brick home. It has a dedicated newspaper roll holder under the locking box.

The “Rust” Secret: It’s metal. Over 5 years, the joints will rust if you live near the coast. You must spray it with a clear coat (like Rust-Oleum) before installing it to seal the seams.

👉 🗝️ Check Price on Amazon (Classic Townhouse)
👉 🛡️ Get Rust-Oleum Clear Coat (The $5 Saver)

3. Best Value – Steel City Tube (Combo Kit)

The Identity: The person who just needs a simple, working newspaper holder.

Most people buy a cheap tube and realize it doesn’t come with a bracket, so they end up using duct tape. Don’t make that mistake. Get the Steel City Combo Kit which includes the “Snap-Shut” tube AND the galvanized steel mounting bracket in the same box.

👉 🗞️ Check Price (Tube + Bracket Included)

4. Best for Security – Mail Boss “Newspaper Holder” Add-On

The Identity: The paranoid (smart) homeowner who worries about theft.

If you have a locking security mailbox (like a Mail Boss), you can’t jam a newspaper inside—it won’t fit through the security slot. You need the Mail Boss Newspaper Holder add-on.

Why it’s cool: It bolts directly to the bottom of your locking mailbox. It is made of the same 12-gauge steel, so a baseball bat won’t dent it.

👉 🔒 Check Price on Amazon (Mail Boss Add-On)

Buying Guide: The “Invisible” Installation Problem

As with most home improvement projects, most 1-star reviews come from installation frustration, not the box itself. Before installing, check the official USPS Mailbox Guidelines to ensure you have the correct height (usually 41-45 inches).

• If buying a Plastic Box (Step2): You usually need a 4×4 Wood Post to slide it over. These rarely mount to metal poles.
• If buying a Tube: You almost always need a Universal Mounting Bracket unless you plan to use zip ties (don’t do that).

Verdict: What is the Best Newspaper Mailbox?

• For maximum dryness (Snow/Heavy Rain): Get the Step2 MailMaster. It is the best newspaper mailbox for wet climates because the molded plastic has zero leaks.
• For the cheapest fix: Get the Steel City Tube + Bracket.

💡 Pro Tip: If your carrier keeps leaving the paper in the rain, leave a frozen bottle of water or a Gatorade in the tube on a hot day. You’d be amazed how quickly they start aiming for the back of the box after that.

Common Questions About Newspaper Mailboxes

Do newspaper mailboxes have locking features?
Most standard newspaper tubes do not lock because the carrier needs instant access. If you need security, we recommend a locking main mailbox (like Mail Boss) with a separate, open holder for the paper attached to the bottom.

What is the most affordable newspaper mailbox option?
The Steel City Poly Tube is the most affordable reliable option. Avoid the $10 flexible plastic hooks, as they tend to crack in the winter sun after one season.